Wonders & Marvels

History and science, checked against the sources.

The FBI's John Wilkes Booth File: Escape Rumors, a Boot and a Diary

Between 1922 and 1977 the Bureau answered letters about Booth's supposed escape and examined his boot and diary. What the released file shows, and what it does not.

By · Published · 8 min read

John Wilkes Booth died on the porch of Richard Garrett’s farmhouse in Virginia on April 26, 1865, twelve days after he shot Abraham Lincoln.1 Yet the federal agency that became the FBI kept a file on him that runs from 1922 to 1977. The released pages are few, and most of them are routine. Read in order, they show a government office being drawn again and again toward one of the most persistent legends in American history, and declining, with varying degrees of conviction, to treat it as a case.2

The file has three main episodes: letters in 1922 and 1923 to William J. Burns, then head of the Bureau of Investigation, about the idea that Booth had escaped; a 1948 laboratory examination of the boot cut from Booth’s leg; and a 1977 laboratory examination of his pocket diary.2 None of them was an investigation in the ordinary sense, and in 1977 the Bureau said so explicitly.

The legend the letters were about

The escape story took its best-known form after January 13, 1903, when a man known as David E. George died of poisoning in a hotel in Enid, Oklahoma Territory. The local doctor called it self-administered. Stories soon spread that George had claimed to be Booth, and his embalmed body was put on view at the furniture store that served as the town’s funeral home.34

A Memphis lawyer, Finis L. Bates, then came to Enid and identified the body as a man he said he had known in Granbury, Texas, in the 1870s as John St. Helen. According to Bates, St. Helen, believing himself near death, had confessed to being Booth, and later gave a full account of the assassination and his escape.3 In that account another man was killed in Garrett’s barn and passed off as Booth, and Vice President Andrew Johnson had been behind the plot.4

In 1907 Bates published the story as Escape and Suicide of John Wilkes Booth. His preface says he had become satisfied “that John Wilkes Booth was not killed, as has been supposed, at the Garrett home in Virginia, on the 26th day of April, 1865.”5 He eventually obtained the body and rented it out to showmen. The Oklahoma Historical Society’s account says it was displayed during the 1904 St. Louis World’s Fair, while History.com dates Bates’s custody to around 1907; either way, it traveled with carnivals and sideshows for decades.34 A historian of the legend for the Oklahoma Historical Society notes that some of what Bates published about St. Helen was inconsistent with documented facts, and that the Enid body’s reported leg injury did not match the side on which Booth’s leg was broken.3

Two letters to Director Burns, 1922 and 1923

The first item in the file is a handwritten letter dated May 8, 1922, from Excelsior Springs, Missouri. The writer, whose name is redacted, told Burns about a local man named Booth who said that Lincoln’s assassin was still alive and had written to him some fifteen years earlier.6 Burns answered on May 12 in two sentences. The Bureau, he wrote, was “inclined to believe official records” in Booth’s case and did not think “any investigation is necessary.”6

The second exchange is stranger. In late December 1922 a correspondent in Enid, the town where David E. George had died, mailed Burns a copy of the Bates book and asked him to read it, saying that its supporters were ready to submit proofs.6 Burns replied on January 10, 1923, in a tone very different from his earlier letter. He had gone over the volume “with considerable interest,” he wrote, and found in it “very strong evidence” for the long-standing belief that Booth had got away and lived for many years after killing Lincoln.6

He then closed the door: “This Department has no means of verification other than historic works, as the original case was handled by the military authorities.”6 Burns was saying, in effect, that the events of 1865 lay outside his Bureau’s records and reach. The released file contains nothing further on the escape theory. An enclosure sheet notes that the 321-page book itself was in the file but was not copied for release.6

How seriously to take Burns’s praise is a fair question. It reads as a courteous reply to a persistent correspondent as much as a considered judgment, and the file records no follow-up of any kind. It is evidence of what one official wrote in 1923, not evidence that Booth escaped.

A boot, and a name inside it

The next episode had nothing to do with the escape story. On November 24, 1948, Irving C. Root, superintendent of the National Capital Parks, sent the FBI the left boot that Booth wore on the night of the assassination and that Dr. Samuel Mudd later cut from his broken leg. Root asked for infrared or other photography to make the writing inside it legible, adding: “So far no laboratory has ever examined the boot in any way.”6

The laboratory photographed the boot under ultraviolet and infrared light. Its report of November 30, 1948, was cautious: “While it was not possible to read any of the writing with certainty, it does appear that the top line is composed of three words, the first of which is HENRY.” The second line seemed to be the numbers 465, the third BROADWAY, and the last a pair of flourished capitals, probably initials.6

Twenty-five years later a private researcher wrote to ask why the laboratory had not read what Mudd described in a statement of April 21, 1865, which the letter renders as “Henry Luz, Maker, 445 Broadway, J. Wilkes,” and why the FBI had been “checking on John Wilkes Booth’s boot eighty-three years after Booth’s death.” The reply of May 30, 1973, signed by acting director William D. Ruckelshaus, explained that the work had been done for the National Park Service “in keeping with our policy of performing Laboratory examinations for other agencies,” and attributed the unreadable passages to the ordinary fading of ink over some eighty-three years.6 A 1939 memorandum in the same file shows a similar pattern of help rather than inquiry: a Washington Post writer wanted old wanted notices for a story, the Bureau found none in its own files, and it had photographic copies made of old notices obtained elsewhere, Booth’s among them.6

The diary under ultraviolet, 1977

The fullest part of the file concerns the small 1864 date book found on Booth’s body, which he had used as a diary.1 Its missing pages had long fed speculation. On May 19, 1977, the National Park Service asked the FBI to examine it, explaining that it had received numerous questions from Lincoln researchers and wanted “to put to rest any question” about whether the diary held invisible writing.6

An FBI memorandum of August 3, 1977, lists the methods used: ultraviolet reflectance, visible fluorescence under ultraviolet excitation, reflected infrared, infrared luminescence and x-ray, plus a search for indented writing. The only unexplained indentations were on a page headed “cash account September,” and they could not be read. The memorandum concluded: “In summation, all appropriate and non-destructive examination techniques have been utilized and nothing of any value has been found.”7

The formal report, dated October 3, 1977, identifies the book as a “Pocket Diary, 1864” with a St. Louis imprint. It calculates that 27 sheets were missing from the block before the page dated June 11, 1864 (25 cut edges were visible), and lists further sheets torn or cut out elsewhere: “In total, there are forty-three full sheets (eighty-six pages) missing from the diary.” It found “no invisible writings, unusual obliterations or alterations or any characteristics of question.” Comparing the diary with two known Booth letters supplied from the National Archives, the examiner concluded that the handwriting in the body of the diary was Booth’s.7

The examination coincided with a newspaper flurry. A Jack Anderson and Les Whitten column in the Washington Post of August 3, 1977, headlined “FBI Probes Lincoln Assassination,” reported that an Americana expert named Joseph Lynch had found what appeared to be the missing pages among artifacts belonging to heirs of Edwin Stanton, Lincoln’s secretary of war, and at least one reader wrote to the FBI asking for copies.7 The Bureau’s answer was flat: the pages “have not been submitted to the FBI for examination and we are not aware of their whereabouts.” When a television reporter visited the laboratory, the examiner “made it clear” to him “that the FBI was not investigating this matter but merely providing laboratory assistance” at the Park Service’s request.7

What the file shows, and what it does not

The released file does not show that the FBI ever investigated whether Booth escaped. It shows one director dismissing the idea in 1922, the same director writing an admiring but noncommittal note about Bates’s book in 1923, and, from 1948 onward, a laboratory doing technical work on two artifacts for the National Park Service. In 1977 the Bureau went out of its way to deny that it was investigating anything.67

The case against the escape story rests on other evidence. Several people who knew Booth identified the body aboard the monitor Montauk in April 1865. Dr. John Frederick May found the scar from a tumor he had removed from Booth’s neck, and a hotel clerk recognized the initials “J.W.B.” tattooed in India ink. The autopsy recorded a fracture of the left fibula. The body was buried at the Washington Arsenal, moved in 1867, and released to the Booth family in 1869, when it was identified again before burial in the family plot at Green Mount Cemetery in Baltimore.18

The legend has continued all the same. In 1931 a group of Chicago physicians examined the Enid mummy and declared its features consistent with Booth’s.9 In 1994 distant relatives and others petitioned to exhume the Green Mount grave. A Baltimore newspaper noted that the alternative account was “based almost entirely on a book authored by Finis Bates.” Judge Joseph H. H. Kaplan refused the petition, and the Court of Special Appeals affirmed in June 1996.10 The mummy itself dropped from public view by the late 1970s, and none of the sources consulted for this article knows where it is.49

The FBI file, then, is less a record of a hunt than a record of the legend’s reach. It shows that the story could get a respectful reply from the head of a federal bureau in 1923, and that half a century later the government still found it worth putting a diary under ultraviolet light to show there was nothing hidden in it.

Footnotes

  1. Norton, “John Wilkes Booth’s Final Hours and the Positive Identification of His Body.” ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  2. The Black Vault, “Declassified Presidential Assassin FBI Files,” Booth entry. ↩ ↩2

  3. Logsdon, “Booth Legend,” Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  4. Klein, History.com, 2015. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4

  5. Bates 1907, Preface. ↩

  6. FBI, John Wilkes Booth release, part 1 (Black Vault booth1.pdf): letters of May 8 and 12, 1922; December 1922 and January 10, 1923; November 24 and 30, 1948; May 30, 1973; July 25, 1939 memorandum; May 19, 1977. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12

  7. FBI, John Wilkes Booth release, parts 3 and 4 (Black Vault booth3.pdf, booth4.pdf): memoranda of August 3 and 4, 1977; August 1977 correspondence; Laboratory report of October 3, 1977, pp. 1-5. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5

  8. Norton, “John Wilkes Booth’s Autopsy.” ↩

  9. Rossen, Mental Floss, 2025. ↩ ↩2

  10. Baumann, The Daily Record, June 5, 1996. ↩

Sources

  1. Federal Bureau of Investigation. John Wilkes Booth, FOIA release, part 1 of 4 (files 62-2376, 62-4403, 95-28874, 95-216208, 94-8-6). Correspondence of May 1922 to January 1923; National Park Service request and FBI Laboratory report, November 1948; inquiry and reply, May 1973; National Park Service request, May 19, 1977; memorandum of July 25, 1939. Mirrored by The Black Vault. www.theblackvault.com/documents/fbifiles/booth1.pdf Used for: Excelsior Springs letter of May 8, 1922, and Burns's reply of May 12, 1922; Enid letter of December 1922 enclosing Bates's book, and Burns's reply of January 10, 1923; Irving C. Root's letter of November 24, 1948; FBI Laboratory report of November 30, 1948; the 1973 inquiry and the reply of May 30, 1973 signed by acting director William D. Ruckelshaus; NPS letter of May 19, 1977; 1939 memorandum on old wanted notices; redaction and enclosure sheets.
  2. Federal Bureau of Investigation. John Wilkes Booth, FOIA release, parts 3 and 4 of 4 (file 95-216208). FBI Laboratory memoranda of August 3, 4 and 11, 1977; correspondence of August 1977, including a clipping of the Jack Anderson and Les Whitten column 'FBI Probes Lincoln Assassination' (Washington Post, August 3, 1977); Report of the FBI Laboratory to J. Dunning, National Park Service, October 3, 1977. Mirrored by The Black Vault. www.theblackvault.com/documents/fbifiles/booth4.pdf Used for: Diary delivered May 19, 1977; techniques used; indented writing on the September cash account page; 'nothing of any value' summation; WRC-TV visit and statement that the FBI was not investigating; Joseph Lynch 'missing pages' inquiries and the FBI reply; October 3, 1977 report: description of the 1864 pocket diary, 27 sheets missing before June 11, 43 full sheets missing in total, no invisible writing, handwriting matched to two known Booth letters.
  3. The Black Vault. Declassified Presidential Assassin FBI Files: Booth, John Wilkes (index entry). www.theblackvault.com/documentarchive/fbi-files-presidential-assassins/ Used for: Description of the release as 1922-23 Burns correspondence on the escape theory, a 1948 boot examination and a 1977 diary examination.
  4. Bates, F. L. (1907). Escape and Suicide of John Wilkes Booth, Assassin of President Lincoln. Memphis: Pilcher Printing Company. Internet Archive scan (Lincoln National Life Foundation copy). archive.org/details/escapesuicideofj07bate Used for: Bates's stated thesis in the preface that Booth was not killed at the Garrett farm; publication in 1907 in Memphis; Bates's account of St. Helen and of David E. George at Enid.
  5. Logsdon, G. (2010, January 15). Booth Legend. The Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture. Oklahoma Historical Society. www.okhistory.org/publications/enc/entry?entry=BO016 Used for: Death of David E. George at the Grand Avenue Hotel, Enid, January 13, 1903; diagnosis of self-administered poisoning; display of the embalmed body; leg-injury discrepancy; Bates's arrival and identification of the body as John St. Helen; Bates's claim to have known St. Helen in Granbury, Texas, in the early 1870s; inconsistencies in Bates's account; exhibition at the 1904 St. Louis fair; later history of the body.
  6. Klein, C. (2015, April 17). The John Wilkes Booth Mummy That Toured America. History.com. www.history.com/articles/the-john-wilkes-booth-mummy-that-toured-america Used for: St. Helen's claimed confession and the story that another man died in the Garrett barn; claim that Andrew Johnson was behind the plot; Bates gaining custody of the body around 1907 and renting it out; sale to William Evans after Bates's death in 1923; later owners; 1931 Chicago examination; mummy last seen publicly in the late 1970s.
  7. Rossen, J. (2025, October 21). How Kathy Bates's Grandfather Got Wrapped Up in the Mystery of a Mummified John Wilkes Booth. Mental Floss. www.mentalfloss.com/history/kathy-bates-grandfather-john-wilkes-booth-mummy-myst Used for: 1931 examination by Chicago physician Orlando Scott and his conclusions; sale to Jay Gould's show in 1937; unknown present whereabouts of the mummy.
  8. Norton, R. J. John Wilkes Booth's Final Hours and the Positive Identification of His Body. Abraham Lincoln's Assassination (rogerjnorton.com). rogerjnorton.com/Lincoln40.html Used for: Booth's death at the Garrett farm on April 26, 1865; items found on the body including an 1864 date book kept as a diary; identification aboard the Montauk by people who knew him, including Dr. John Frederick May (surgical scar) and hotel clerk Charles Dawson (initials in India ink); second identification in 1869; 1994 petition and its rejection.
  9. Baumann, G. C. (1996, June 5). Who's Lying in Booth's Tomb? Court Decision Buries Answer. The Daily Record (Baltimore), p. 7. Reproduced in Maryland State Archives Special Collections (SC 3520-011679). www.msa.maryland.gov/megafile/msa/speccol/sc3500/sc3520/011600/011679/pdf/rec5ju Used for: 1994 petition by distant relatives and others to exhume the Green Mount grave; the escape account relied 'almost entirely' on Bates's book; Judge Joseph H. H. Kaplan's ruling against exhumation and the June 4, 1996 appellate affirmance by Chief Judge Alan M. Wilner.
  10. Norton, R. J. John Wilkes Booth's Autopsy. Abraham Lincoln's Assassination (rogerjnorton.com). rogerjnorton.com/Lincoln83.html Used for: Identification aboard the monitor Montauk, including Dr. John Frederick May and Charles Dawson; Surgeon General Barnes's autopsy report recording a fracture of the left fibula; burial at the Washington Arsenal, reburial in 1867, release and identification in 1869; burial at Green Mount Cemetery, Baltimore, June 26, 1869.

What the evidence does not settle

Points where sources disagree, or that we could not confirm. We list them rather than smooth them over.

  • vault.fbi.gov returned HTTP 403 from this environment. The FBI file was read instead as page images in the four PDF parts mirrored by The Black Vault (booth1.pdf to booth4.pdf), cross-checked against the Internet Archive's OCR text of the same release. Every quotation from the file was checked word for word against the rendered page image, not the OCR.
  • The handwritten 1922 letter from Excelsior Springs, Missouri, and the December 1922 letter from Enid, Oklahoma, are difficult to read in places and the writers' names are redacted. The article paraphrases them and does not quote them.
  • A handwritten marginal note on the Enid letter appears to refer to a memorandum to 'Mr. Hoover' dated 1/10/23 (J. Edgar Hoover was then the Bureau's assistant director). The reading is uncertain and the article does not rely on it.
  • The 1948 FBI Laboratory report bears J. Edgar Hoover's signature as Director, as all such reports did; the article does not suggest he took a personal interest.
  • The file does not show whether Burns acted on the Bates book after January 1923. The released pages contain no further correspondence on the escape theory, and the Bates volume itself was listed as an enclosure that was not copied for release.
  • The referring Fox News article says the FBI confirmed 27 missing sheets in the diary. The FBI report of October 3, 1977, counts 27 sheets missing from the block before June 11, 1864, and 43 full sheets missing in total. The article gives the report's own figures.
  • Sources disagree about the injured leg of the Enid body and the later mummy. Logsdon (Oklahoma Historical Society) and Klein (History.com) say the right leg, while Booth's fracture was in the left; Rossen (Mental Floss) reports that the 1931 Chicago examiners described a slightly shortened left leg. The article notes the disagreement rather than resolving it.
  • The 1996 Court of Special Appeals opinion in Kline v. Green Mount Cemetery could not be fetched (host blocked). The court history is taken from a contemporary Daily Record report and from Roger Norton's summary.
  • Independent re-check (2026-11-10): the s8 URL originally pointed to Norton's autopsy page (Lincoln83.html), not the 'Final Hours' page its citation names. s8 now points to Lincoln40.html, and the autopsy page is cited separately as s10.
  • Roger J. Norton's 'Abraham Lincoln's Assassination' site is a long-running specialist reference rather than peer-reviewed scholarship. It is used for the 1865 identification and autopsy and the 1869 burial, and it transcribes the primary statements it relies on.
  • The location of the mummy after the 1970s is unknown in all sources read.

Corrections and updates

No corrections have been issued for this article.

Spotted an error? Email editor@wondersandmarvels.com with the passage and a source. See our corrections policy.

About this article: written for the new Wonders & Marvels by the Wonders & Marvels Research Desk, with AI-assisted research and drafting. It is an original work and does not reproduce any article previously published at this address.