George Cheyne's English Malady and the Price of Sensibility
In 1733 a Bath physician who had once weighed 32 stone called nervous illness a disease of wealth and refinement, and told readers it struck the quickest minds first.
By Wonders & Marvels Research Desk · Published · 9 min read
In 1733 a physician practicing at Bath published a book whose title named an illness after his adopted country. George Cheyne, a Scot born in Aberdeenshire in the early 1670s, called it The English Malady, and he meant by it a whole family of complaints: spleen, vapours, lowness of spirits, and the “hypochondriacal” and “hysterical” disorders that filled the consulting rooms of the well-off.123 The book was a medical treatise, a set of case histories and a confession. Its most lasting idea was a flattering one. Nervous suffering, Cheyne argued, was a sign of a finely made body and a quick mind, and the people most exposed to it were the refined, the studious and the rich.
That idea fed into what later writers would call the culture of sensibility, and it drew objections as soon as it appeared. Following it means reading Cheyne’s own pages closely, because almost everything distinctive about the English malady begins with him.
A reproach from across the Channel
Cheyne explains his title in the first lines of the preface. The name, he writes, “is a Reproach universally thrown on this Island by Foreigners, and all our Neighbours on the Continent, by whom nervous Distempers, Spleen, Vapours, and Lowness of Spirits, are in Derision, called the ENGLISH MALADY.” He did not dispute the charge. He listed the reasons he thought it was deserved: a damp climate and changeable weather owing to the island’s position in the ocean, rich soil and “the Richness and Heaviness of our Food,” wealth from “universal Trade,” the idle and sedentary habits of “the better Sort (among whom this Evil mostly rages),” and the fashion for living in large, crowded towns. Together, he said, these had produced disorders “scarce known to our Ancestors,” and he put their share at “almost one third of the Complaints of the People of Condition in England.”1
That last figure is Cheyne’s own estimate, offered without any count behind it, and the story of continental mockery comes to us through his preface rather than from foreign sources. What the passage shows clearly is his framing. The English malady was a disease of a particular place and a particular class, and the class was the one that bought his books.
He was also explaining a fashion he had helped to create. By 1733 Cheyne had spent decades building a practice at Bath among patients with low spirits, and he had already published popular books on gout and on health and long life.2 The new treatise gathered his views into one system and attached it to a memorable name.
Nerves like the keys of an organ
Cheyne had arrived in London in 1702 as a disciple of the Edinburgh professor Archibald Pitcairne, eager to make his name with medicine written in the language of Newtonian mechanics.2 By the 1730s his tone was more pastoral, but the body in The English Malady is still a machine of pipes, fluids and fibres. To make the nerves intelligible to general readers he reached for music. The soul, he suggested, sits somewhere in the brain where the nerves end, “like a Musician in a finely fram’d and well-tun’d Organ-Case; that these Nerves are like Keys, which, being struck on or touch’d, convey the Sound and Harmony to this sentient Principle, or Musician.”1
The image matters because it locates nervous illness in the instrument and not in the player. A weak or broken instrument spoils the music however skilled the musician. Hisao Ishizuka has shown that this way of thinking belonged to a wider “fibre medicine” of roughly 1700 to 1740, in which the tone and elasticity of the body’s solid fibres explained health, temperament and disease. Cheyne was one of its most important exponents, and he had set out a fibre-based account of chronic disease in a Latin treatise of 1725 before writing The English Malady.4 Within this scheme, firm and taut fibres made for a sturdy body, and fine, delicate fibres made for sharper perception along with a greater liability to nervous disorder.4
Cheyne insisted that the result was a real illness. In a note to readers placed before his case histories he wrote that the disease “is as much a bodily Distemper (as I have demonstrated) as the Small-Pox or a Fever.”1
Luxury on the plate
If the nerves were the instrument, the diet of the rich was what put it out of tune. Cheyne brushed aside physicians who blamed the recent rise in nervous complaints, “especially among the Fair Sex,” on coffee, tea, chocolate and snuff. The real cause, he said, was “continued Luxury and Laziness.” His account of how that luxury arrived reads as a commentary on British commerce: “Since our Wealth has increas’d, and our Navigation has been extended, we have ransack’d all the Parts of the Globe to bring together its whole Stock of Materials for Riot, Luxury, and to provoke Excess.”1
He attacked French cookery, imported spices and “Eastern Pickles and Sauces,” and he added a footnote from Seneca: “Do you wonder that Diseases are innumerable? Number the Cooks.” Sprung coaches and ambling horses spared the rich even the jolting of travel. The treatment followed from the cause by the old rule that diseases are cured by their contraries. “If Nervous Disorders are the Diseases of the Wealthy, the Voluptuous, and the Lazy,” he reasoned, then temperance and abstinence were the cure.1
Historian Alexander Wragge-Morley places this argument within a broader eighteenth-century anxiety about the growing supply of imported food and drink, which led Cheyne to worry that new habits of consumption were producing new diseases of mind and body. In his later works on regimen, Cheyne also claimed that the effects of leisure and luxury showed more plainly in women than in men, a view shared by other writers, Diderot among them, who pictured women as especially sensitive registers of social change.5
A diagnosis that flattered
The most influential pages of the book turn the reproach into something closer to a compliment. Cheyne called it “a common Observation” that “Fools, weak or stupid Persons, heavy and dull Souls, are seldom much troubled with Vapours or Lowness of Spirits.” In the note to readers he went further. The disease, he said, “seldom, and I think never happens or can happen, to any but those of the liveliest and quickest natural Parts, whose Faculties are the brightest and most spiritual, and whose Genius is most keen and penetrating, and particularly where there is the most delicate Sensation and Taste, both of Pleasure and Pain.” He could not recall ever seeing “a heavy, dull, earthy, clod-pated Clown, much troubled with nervous Disorders.”1
Even weakness inherited from sickly parents had its compensations. Fine parts that stayed delicate through a frail childhood, Cheyne argued, were “longer preserv’d in their Sensibility and Refinement,” and he cited a proverb: “a Venice Glass will last as long, if well look’d after, and even shine more bright, than a more gross and coarse one.”1
Reviewing Anita Guerrini’s 2000 biography of Cheyne, David Shuttleton summarizes the effect: in the book Cheyne “patriotically configures nervous sensibility as the price of social superiority.”3 Ishizuka notes the same paradox in the medicine of the period, in which the label “English Malady” signalled the superior rank of the nation and of certain individuals, so that a mild case of such a disorder could seem almost desirable.4 Steven Shapin points out that Cheyne aimed his strict diets at “the Valetudinary, the Sedentary, and the Studious,” and that submitting to a low diet could itself become public proof of a refined constitution.2
The compliment had a practical side. Cheyne admitted that nervous illness carried a stigma. Ordinary opinion held it to be “a lower Degree of Lunacy, and the first Step towards a distemper’d Brain,” and in women it was put down to “Daintiness, Fantasticalness or Coquetry.” Naming the disease to a patient was risky: “If I call’d the Case Glandular with nervous Symptoms, they concluded I thought them pox’d, or had the King’s-Evil.” Some patients, he said, had left him over it.1 Recasting the disorder as the burden of fine minds made it easier to own, and easier to treat.
The case of the author
Cheyne closed the book with a long account of his own illness, which Shapin describes as both a warning to the imprudent and an advertisement for the author’s methods.2 He had been a studious, abstemious young man until he reached London, where he found “the Bottle-Companions, the younger Gentry, and Free-Livers, to be the most easy of Access.” He dined and supped in taverns and grew “excessively fat, short-breath’d, Lethargic and Listless.” A frightening attack of giddiness followed, so violent that he held on to the posts of his bed. He tried vomits, purges, bitters, mineral waters and mercury; after one dose of a mercurial powder he believed he would have died “but for an Over-dose of Laudanum after it.” His drinking companions “dropt off like autumnal Leaves,” and he went to the country alone while his body seemed to be “melting away like a Snow-ball in Summer.”1
Religious reflection steadied his mind, and a clergyman’s story sent him to Croydon to consult a Dr Taylor, who said he had cured his own epilepsy by living on cow’s milk. Cheyne adopted a milk and vegetable diet and recovered. After a later fever he went back by degrees to wine and meat, and over the next ten or twelve years of what he considered temperate eating he grew so large that at his last weighing “I exceeded 32 Stone.” He could barely climb a flight of stairs. His legs broke out in ulcers that healed only after another course of mercury, and some years later a severe fever in the summer of 1723 drove him back to milk and vegetables for good.1
By 1733 his regimen was “Milk, with Tea, Coffee, Bread and Butter, mild Cheese,” along with salads, fruits, seeds and roots such as potatoes and turnips, no wine, and bed at ten.1 The case made the argument of the whole book personal. Cheyne presented himself as a man of lively parts whose body had been ruined by English plenty and restored by its opposite. Laudanum, which Cheyne credited with saving him from his own mercury, appears again a century later in a very different invalid’s story: Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s use of the drug.
Readers, patients and a skeptic
The book sold. Shapin counts six editions of The English Malady within six years, and a sixth edition dated 1735 survives.26 Cheyne’s patients and correspondents included Alexander Pope, John Gay, the novelist and printer Samuel Richardson and the Countess of Huntingdon, and John Wesley copied whole sections of Cheyne into his own popular medical handbook.2 Shuttleton notes that Cheyne’s crisis also turned him toward a pious, sentimental religion, and he quotes Guerrini’s verdict that Cheyne belonged to an Enlightenment of “sensibility and sociability.”3
Samuel Johnson recommended the book and rejected its flattering premise. On Easter Day 1776, James Boswell recorded, Johnson “recommended Dr. Cheyne’s books.” When Boswell objected that Cheyne was reckoned whimsical, Johnson answered, “So he was, (said he,) in some things; but there is no end of objections,” and added, “I would not have you read anything else of Cheyne, but his book on Health, and his English Malady.” That July, after Boswell wrote of a return of melancholy, Johnson replied: “Read Cheyne’s English Malady; but do not let him teach you a foolish notion that melancholy is a proof of acuteness.”7
Johnson’s sentence names the problem precisely. Cheyne’s dietary advice could be judged on its results, and Johnson thought his books worth reading. The claim that nervous suffering marked a superior mind was something else: a social idea presented as physiology. Ishizuka traces how that “medico-cultural myth of nervous sensibility,” the belief that finer nerves made a finer person, grew stronger as the culture of sensibility matured from the middle of the century.4
Modern readers should be careful not to translate Cheyne’s categories too quickly into present-day diagnoses. As Shapin observes, what early modern people suffered from when they suffered from “the Hyp” remains a puzzle, even if the suffering itself is not in doubt.2 What The English Malady does show is how a physician’s account of illness could carry a theory of class, nation and character with it, and how a patient’s own case could become the most persuasive evidence in the book.
Footnotes
-
Cheyne 1733, Preface I-II; Introduction pp. 4-5; pp. 21, 49-53, 158; Advertisement pp. 259-262; The Case of the Author pp. 325-362. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8 ↩9 ↩10 ↩11 ↩12
-
Shapin, London Review of Books 22(15), 2000. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4 ↩5 ↩6 ↩7 ↩8
-
Ishizuka 2012, Medical History 56(4), sections on fibre theory and fibre-based constitutions, with note 21. ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Wragge-Morley 2026, Medical History 70(1), introduction and section on luxury and women. ↩
-
Internet Archive record, The English Malady, sixth edition, 1735. ↩
-
Boswell, Life of Johnson, ed. Hill, vol. 3: April 7, 1776, and Johnson to Boswell, July 2, 1776, with Hill’s note 77. ↩
Sources
- Cheyne, G. (1733). The English Malady: or, a Treatise of Nervous Diseases of All Kinds, as Spleen, Vapours, Lowness of Spirits, Hypochondriacal, and Hysterical Distempers, &c. In Three Parts. London: G. Strahan and J. Leake (Bath). First edition. Internet Archive scans of the York University (University of Toronto collection) and Duke University copies. archive.org/details/englishmaladyort00cheyuoft Used for: Preface sections I-II (title as a foreign reproach, causes, 'almost one third'); Introduction pp. 4-5 (musician and organ simile); p. 21 (sensibility and refinement, Venice glass proverb); pp. 49-53 (coffee, tea, chocolate and snuff dismissed; wealth and navigation; French cookery and Seneca note; fools seldom troubled); p. 158 (diseases of the wealthy, cure by contraries); Advertisement pp. 259-262 (stigma, 'Quack's Bill', bodily distemper, liveliest parts, clod-pated clown); The Case of the Author pp. 325-362 (London taverns, vertigo, mercury and laudanum, friends departing, milk diet from Dr Taylor of Croydon, 32 stone, 1723 illness, regimen).
- Boswell, J. Life of Johnson, Volume 3 (1776-1780), ed. G. B. Hill (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1887). Project Gutenberg eBook #9180. www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/9180 Used for: Johnson's recommendation of Cheyne's books on Easter Day, April 7, 1776, and his remark that Cheyne was whimsical 'in some things'; Johnson's letter to Boswell of July 2, 1776 ('Read Cheyne's English Malady...'); Hill's note that Cheyne once weighed thirty-two stones and recommended a milk, seed and vegetable diet.
- Shapin, S. (2000, August 10). Fat is a manifest tissue [review of Anita Guerrini, Obesity and Depression in the Enlightenment: The Life and Times of George Cheyne]. London Review of Books, 22(15). www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v22/n15/steven-shapin/fat-is-a-manifest-tissue Used for: Cheyne's Aberdeenshire birth, Edinburgh training under Pitcairne, arrival in London in 1702 and Royal Society election; Newtonian early works; practice at Bath for patients with lowness of spirits; 'Case of the Author' as warning and advertisement; English Malady in six editions within six years; patients including Pope, Gay, Richardson and the Countess of Huntingdon; Wesley and Fielding; diet tailored to 'the Valetudinary, the Sedentary, and the Studious'; sensibility vouched for by low diet; uncertainty over what 'the Hyp' was.
- Ishizuka, H. (2012). 'Fibre Body': The Concept of Fibre in Eighteenth-century Medicine, c.1700-40. Medical History, 56(4), 562-584. DOI: 10.1017/mdh.2012.74. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3483762/ Used for: Fibre-based solidism of the early eighteenth century and Cheyne's place in it (De natura fibrae, 1725); elasticity of fibres; constitution and social rank read into fibre tone; delicate fibres linked to nervous disorder and superior mental capacity; 'English Malady' as an epithet signalling superior rank; intensification of the 'medico-cultural myth of nervous sensibility' from mid-century.
- Shuttleton, D. E. (2001). Review of Anita Guerrini, Obesity and Depression in the Enlightenment: The Life and Times of George Cheyne (Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 2000). Medical History, 45(4), 551-552. DOI: 10.1017/S0025727300068551. doi.org/10.1017/S0025727300068551 Used for: Cheyne's dates (1671/2-1743) and practice at Bath; the Author's case as candid account of a physical and spiritual crisis in which he 'patriotically configures nervous sensibility as the price of social superiority'; his turn to sentimentalist pietism; Guerrini's view of him as a man of the Enlightenment of 'sensibility and sociability'; doubt that Cheyne returned to Scotland after his first crisis.
- Wragge-Morley, A. (2026). Habit, medicine, and society in 18th-century Britain. Medical History, 70(1), 1-19. DOI: 10.1017/mdh.2025.10042. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12917427/ Used for: Anxieties over imported food and drink led Cheyne to worry that new habits of consumption produced new pathologies; Cheyne held that the effects of leisure and luxury consumption showed more in women than in men (Wragge-Morley cites Cheyne's Natural Method, 1742, for this); Diderot used similar ideas.
- Cheyne, G. (1735). The English Malady: or, a Treatise of Nervous Diseases of All Kinds. The sixth edition. Internet Archive item record (Eighteenth Century collection). archive.org/details/bim_eighteenth-century_the-english-malady-or-_cheyne-george_ Used for: Existence of a sixth edition dated 1735 (catalogue record only).
What the evidence does not settle
Points where sources disagree, or that we could not confirm. We list them rather than smooth them over.
- The claim that foreigners called nervous illness 'the English Malady' rests on Cheyne's own preface; no independent eighteenth-century foreign usage was checked for this article. His estimate that nervous disorders made up almost a third of the complaints of 'People of Condition' is his own figure, offered without data.
- Cheyne's birth year is given as 1671 by Shapin (2000) and as 1671/2 by Shuttleton (2001); the article says only 'early 1670s'.
- Shapin (2000) writes that after his first breakdown Cheyne retreated to Scotland; Shuttleton (2001), reviewing the same biography, says he needs 'more convincing' that Cheyne returned to Scotland after his first crisis. Cheyne's own Case says only that he retired 'to the Country'. The article follows Cheyne's wording.
- Modern diagnoses are not attempted. Shapin notes that what early modern sufferers of 'the Hyp' had in modern terms is an open question.
Corrections and updates
No corrections have been issued for this article.
Spotted an error? Email editor@wondersandmarvels.com with the passage and a source. See our corrections policy.
About this article: written for the new Wonders & Marvels by the Wonders & Marvels Research Desk, with AI-assisted research and drafting. It is an original work and does not reproduce any article previously published at this address.