When the Only Safe Sex was with Vampires

in Sex and Childbirth, Women and Society

By Karen Essex

Women with "Nymphomania"When answering questions about my latest novel, Dracula in Love, I am inevitably asked about the sequences that readers find the most chilling and frightening – the scenes in the Victorian insane asylum. Surely those shocking scenarios, like the fantasy scenes of vampirism, are products of the author’s perverse imagination? Ironically, the answer is no; the asylum sequences are based on painstaking research. Truth, as it turns out, is always is stranger than fiction.

Dracula in Love retells Bram Stoker’s original story from the perspective of the vampire’s muse, Mina Harker, and in the process, turns the story on its ear, freeing Mina from her role as “victim,” and putting her at the center of her own story. A good deal of Stoker’s book takes place in an asylum. I wanted to utilize that Gothic setting in my book, but I also wanted to paint the asylum as it actually would have been at the time – full of women incarcerated for having what we today would consider normal sexual and other desires.

In the course of my research, I quickly discovered that women in the 1890s had more to fear from their own culture than from vampires. I read the psychiatric journals of the period, which prescribed bizarre treatments for ladies who were “hysterical,” which usually turned out to mean that they were “excitable in the presence of men.” In many instances, the desire to read all day or engage in intellectual studies, were also regarded as symptoms of mental illness in the female. Young women were committed to asylums for doing cartwheels in mixed company, for desiring sex with someone other than one’s husband, or for staring seductively at a man. Most behavior that showed spunk, spirit, or sexual need, was pathologized.

All sorts of harrowing and torturous cures were developed to “settle” these women – restraints, forced housework (to help them remember their true natures), repeated plunges in ice water, and force-feeding, to name a few. As mental illness in females was thought to originate in the womb, doctors also were obsessed with menstrual cycles, figuring that if a patient’s cycle could be regulated to a strict 28-30 day cycle, the “illness” of wanting to have sex or read books all day, would disappear. Not coincidentally, an irregular cycle was also considered a sign of mental illness and required treatment.

Curious as to whether these “cures” were actually implemented, I visited the archives of Victorian mental hospitals and read physicians’ reports from the late 1800s, often in the doctors’ own handwriting. Reading of young women committed for losing interest in housework, for lying about sexual encounters, or in one case, of a fifteen year old girl diagnosed with hysteria because she refused to stick her tongue out for the doctor’s tongue depressor, was heartbreaking.

Worse yet were the treatments, which often involved restraints to “pacify” the women. Women’s “fluttering, nervous hands” were thought to be a sign of hysteria, and the proscribed treatment was confinement – cuffs, muffs, straps, and strait jackets. Psychiatrists figured that if they could only calm the woman’s hands long enough, the patient would be soothed, hence, cured. More often than not, after prolonged periods of restraint, women’s spirits were entirely broken, at which point, they were allowed to return home. One of the most amusing anecdotes I ran across was the euphemism of “camisole” for the strait jacket because wearing it soothed a lady’s nerves in the same way that putting on a lovely garment might.

Think about that next time you slip into a bustier!

Though the Victorian era had its charms and pleasures – and I do explore those as well in Dracula in Love – it was a dangerous time to be a woman. If I were living in that era, I would surely have been committed. And I’m guessing that if you are reading this, you might have been my cellmate.

About the author: Karen Essex is the best-selling author of Dracula in Love, Leonardo’s Swans, Stealing Athena, and two acclaimed biographical novels, Kleopatra and Pharaoh. She lives and works in London and Los Angeles. To learn more about Karen’s work, please visit her website: www.karenessex.com.

Dracula in Love

Giveaway is closed.

Would you like an email notification of other drawings? Sign up for our weekly digest in the sidebar.

  • Jamiemcin

    Hi, this book sounds interesting! I would love to get a copy. :)

    Q: What is your favorite book featuring a female character who is either insane or thought to be insane?
    A: Susanna Kaysen: Girl, Interrupted or Sylvia Plath: The Bell Jar

    Jamie McIntosh
    802 N College Ave., apt. 4
    Bloomington IN, 47404

  • Cynthia

    I’m not sure whether it’d be my favorite today, but I still remember reading Woman on the Edge of Time, by Marge Piercy, in college, and discussing the ways women were institutionalized by their husbands/families. Simply because the women had no power. And this was only decades ago, not hundreds of years. That, in itself, was chilling to me at the time. Interesting (scary) post!

  • Alger

    Please consider me

  • Lizzieheff

    I love vampires and Dracula!

    My favorite book with a possibly crazy lady is The Woman in White by Wilkie Collins.

  • Eleanor

    Hmmm. . . which book to pick?  Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper” is a fantastic short story about a woman confined for “hysteria.” 

  • sploo

    I like Ista, the Dowager Royina of Chalion – also known as Mad Ista – in Lois McMaster Bujold’s “The Curse of Chalion.” 

  • Agilsdorf

    The Awakening by Kate Chopin

  • Terry Martini

    I have loved Karen’s other books especially Leonardo’s Swans and would love to read this one.  My favorite book featuring a female character thought to be insane is Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys.

    tmrtini at gmail dot com

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sarah-Roche/100000504983148 Sarah Roche

    This book sounds great! I would love to read it!

    My favorite would be “The Yellow Wallpaper,” even though it is a short story and not a book. 

    Reading through the comments has helped me to add some items to my reading list. 

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sarah-Roche/100000504983148 Sarah Roche

    Oops- logging in via Facebook made a double post. Sorry about that!

  • RevMaggie

    Dracula In Love, promises to be another superb accomplishment of Karen Essex’s determined and thorough research. I look forward to reading it. A book that follows this same thread that I highly recommend is, The Lives They Left Behind: Suitcases from a State Hospital Attic, by Darby Penney co-authored with Peter Stastny. The uncanny photographs by Lisa Rinzler poignantly document this saga of “lives left behind” at Willard State Hospital in New York.

  • Eric Laursen

    My favorite was Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House.  There’s a scene where Eleanor runs around the house at night, and you’re not sure whether she’s mad, or dead, or both.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=599103832 Cathie Veres

    How sad is it that I can’t think of any books with a mad or possible mad female lead???  That being said I’d love to read this.

    lovemybabysquid@yahoo.com

  • http://www.facebook.com/mechampion Martha Champion

    Sounds great- I love historical novels.  Nellie Bly- Girl Reporter (very old book) About her expose of insane asylums- Her report, later published in book form as Ten Days in a Mad- House, caused a sensation and brought her lasting fame.  Sounds like the same issues.

  • T2heath

    The Last Queen, by C. W. Gortner, is a wonderful book about the woman known to history as Juana la Loca, and it left me thinking she was not mad at all.

  • Peter Culos

    Wow, tough question.  I recall a book about the Smuttynose murders but I can’t remember the name.

  • http://twitter.com/dujyt Judy

    Don’t know if the giveaway is still going on but I knew I shouldn’t miss the opportunity to suggest the novel “One Thousand White Women: The Journals of May Dodd” by Jim Fergus as an example of a lead female character thought to be insane. Not only May, but most of the women referenced in the title were thought to be insane or mentally unstable, so they were considered perfect specimens for an “experiment” in matching white women with Native American men to produce an “assimilated” generation.  I still remember scenes from this novel after a decade.

Previous post:

Next post: